Written by: Borut Furlan; Seas of the World with Borut Furlan
Underwater photography at Aliwal Shoal is a major challenge
Aliwal Shoal is located roughly as far south of the equator as the northern part of the Red Sea is to the north, yet the conditions there are completely different. Marine conditions around Aliwal Shoal are highly variable and unpredictable. Because it lies on the edge of the open ocean, waves are a constant feature and are sometimes so large that diving is impossible. The reef is continuously swept by strong ocean currents, alternating between northern currents from the Indian Ocean and southern currents from the Atlantic. Conditions in the sea can change completely within an hour. When a northern current washes over the reef, the water is usually warm, blue, and offers excellent visibility. Conversely, the southern Atlantic current brings cold, green water with poor visibility. Visibility can range from just thirty centimetres to over thirty metres, and the temperature fluctuates between eighteen and twenty-six degrees Celsius. Due to such fluctuating hydrometeorological conditions, diving—and underwater photography in particular—presents a considerable challenge.
The reef’s biodiversity is exceptional
Biologically speaking, the marine environment is subtropical. Owing to the intermittently low temperatures, coral growth is modest; the exposed sections of the rocky reef are mostly overgrown with algae, large sponges, and scattered hard corals. In contrast, sheltered areas, such as various cavities, canyons, and tunnels, are richly covered with diverse, colourful bryozoans and hydrozoans. The fish life is even more intriguing, as the reef hosts numerous colourful tropical fish species, for which the water is evidently not too cold, alongside cold-water species, particularly from the sea bream family (Sparidae), which feature more subdued grey and silver hues.
The reef’s biodiversity is exceptional, harbouring more than 1,500 species of tropical fish, whereas the entire Red Sea has barely 900 species! It is fascinating to watch small tropical fish grazing on algae (since we are accustomed to seeing them among corals), joined by some of our “old acquaintances”, such as the white seabream or salema, which also occur in South Africa. The rocky reef, rising from a barren and featureless sandy seabed, acts as a magnet for fish by providing food and shelter. The most imposing inhabitants of the reef, however, are the large potato groupers (Epinephelus tukula), which are so accustomed to divers that they allow themselves to be stroked!
The reef is also home to numerous invertebrates, with more nudibranch species than in many tropical seas. In fact, in South Africa, the further south towards the colder water one travels, the more nudibranchs one finds. Only recently have I also begun discovering the microcosm of this remarkable habitat, as its algae and sponges host numerous tiny crustaceans, some less than a millimetre in size, which are a great rarity in other seas.

Apex predators
Above all, Aliwal Shoal is a magnet for large pelagic predators that frequently visit on hunting forays, as the abundance of reef fish provides a well-stocked pantry. The main predators are tuna, various trevallies and jacks, sharks, and dolphins. It is precisely these large predators that have made the reef world-famous, drawing divers from every continent.

There are no major water temperature differences between summer and winter. Generally, warm currents from the north prevail during the summer months (from December to March), whilst cold, green water from the south arrives mainly during the winter months (from June to September). Nevertheless, the reef maintains its own seasonal calendar of pelagic visitors. In the summer months, the reef is visited primarily by numerous shark species, whilst the winter months mark the season for whales and ragged-tooth sharks (Carcharias taurus), affectionately referred to by local divers as Raggies. Blacktip sharks (Carcharhinus limbatus) and dolphins are present throughout the year. It is very difficult to pinpoint the best time to dive at Aliwal Shoal. Diving conditions are, on average, better in the summer months, but captivating marine life is present year-round, so it is best visited repeatedly, across different seasons. Due to the constantly changing conditions, two consecutive dives at the very same site can be completely different! That, indeed, is the appeal of this reef: before a dive, one never knows what will be encountered.
The reef has become a protected area where commercial fishing is strictly prohibited
Due to its exceptional biodiversity and substantial biomass, the reef has become a protected area where commercial fishing is strictly prohibited. Diving (conducted solely by approved dive centres) and, to some extent, recreational hook-and-line angling are permitted, whereas spearfishing is not allowed.

I recommend the dive centre and hotel Blue Ocean Dive Resort (BODR)
Whenever I travel to Umkomaas, I always go to the dive centre and hotel Blue Ocean Dive Resort (BODR), as its owner, Gary Snodgrass, and I have become good friends. I now enjoy special privileges there, which greatly facilitates my underwater photography; every day, they ask me what I would like to see and photograph the following day (naturally, only if hydrometeorological conditions allow).
In addition to standard air and nitrox dives, BODR facilitates technical trimix dives to other, deeper reefs, as well as dedicated shark dives where the animals are baited with sardines. Almost every year I have undertaken a deep dive as well, but during my last visit in February this year, my focus was primarily on sharks and the microcosm.

Galleries from my visit to Aliwal Shoal
Gallery from my visit to Aliwal Shoal (February 2025)
Umkomaas, South Africa, March 2024
Umkomaas, South Africa, July 2022