Text and photos: Borut Furlan; Seas of the World with Borut Furlan
I was looking forward to diving in Kaş, which was once interesting for its abundance of marine life, especially fish
Kaş is a well-known small resort town on the far south-western tip of Turkey, about a three-hour drive from the large city of Antalya. I dived in Kaş a long time ago, in 2004 and 2007. I remembered warm water, good visibility, a rather barren landscape of bare rock and sand, and an abundance of fish. Although the underwater scenery of Kaş cannot compare with our Adriatic or the Tyrrhenian Sea, diving there was interesting because of the wealth of marine life, especially fish. While the Mediterranean fish fauna of Italy, France and Spain is quite similar to that of the Adriatic, Kaş was already quite different back then. There were a fair number of so-called Lessepsian migrants, fish that have travelled into the Mediterranean through the Suez Canal. The most common among them were rabbitfish (for example Siganus rivulatus), cornetfish (Fistularia commersoni), squirrelfish (Sargocentron rubrum), sweepers (Pempheris vanicolensis) and perhaps the odd pufferfish or triggerfish.

Sweeper Pempheris vanicolensis.
This year, nineteen years after my last visit, I decided to return to Kaş. My purpose was very specific. Since non-native species have recently been appearing in ever greater numbers in the Adriatic too, I reasoned that there must be far more of them in this part of Turkey, which is fairly close to the Suez Canal. I set off in October with my club colleague Magda. For logistical support I chose the Kaş Diving centre, with whom I had already dived on my first visit to Kaş.
Kaş is a very safe town
Diving in Turkey is very relaxed. They have large dive boats with practically everything on board – a kind of floating dive centre. As well as toilets, the boat has a kitchen, two showers, a membrane compressor for filling air and nitrox, helium cylinders for technical diving, tools and equipment storage. I even secured my own “private” tub of fresh water for rinsing my underwater housing. So I left all my equipment, including my camera gear, on the boat, where the captain always slept. But even if no one had been there, the equipment would have been safe, as Kaş is a very safe town. Motorcyclists, for example, leave their helmets on their scooters overnight and nothing ever goes missing. Well, Turkish prisons are a little different from European “hotels”…
Visibility of 30 to 50 metres revealed how empty the sea was
The owner of the dive centre is Levent Aydogmus, who is also an instructor in just about every discipline diving has to offer. Levent personally led our first dive with Magda and me, and once he was satisfied that we could be trusted, we dived on our own for the rest of the trip. He joined us only twice more, and then only to find particular organisms for us.
At first, however, the first dive was quite a disappointment. The water was at least two degrees warmer than the October average (25 °C, and at all depths!) and the visibility was fantastic, somewhere between 30 and 50 metres. But it was precisely this visibility that revealed how empty the sea was. As far as the eye could see, there was nothing but bare rock, sand, water and not a single fish! It was like diving in a huge swimming pool. Once my eyes had adjusted to the new surroundings, fish slowly began to appear, but this was nothing like the great shoals of twenty years ago. To the Turks, who dive in their sea practically every day, this may have seemed perfectly normal, but having returned after such a long time, I noticed an enormous difference.
Despite the initial disappointment, I can say that my visit to Turkey was a success after all. I had come mainly for potential new species, and there were indeed a great many of them!
Ten to twenty lionfish on every dive
Lionfish (Pterois miles), members of the scorpionfish family that divers occasionally encounter in the southern Adriatic, are everywhere in Turkey. On average you see ten to twenty of them on every dive. On the other hand, in all that time (six diving days and fifteen dives) I did not see a single Mediterranean species of scorpionfish!

Juvenile lionfish Pterois miles.
The most numerous, however, were small pufferfish of the species Torquigener flavimaculosus, which were present even in small shoals.

Pufferfish Torquigener flavimaculosus.
The common sea urchins are gone from Turkey
The common sea urchins we are used to in the Adriatic are no longer found in Turkey. They have been replaced by tropical long-spined sea urchins, Diadema setosum, whose spines, almost half a metre long, jut menacingly from under almost every larger rock.

Sea urchin Diadema setosum and cardinalfish Cheilodipterus quinquelineatus.
Tiny tropical cardinalfish of the species Cheilodipterus quinquelineatus have found refuge among the spines, while I did not see a single one of our red Mediterranean Apogon imberbis.

Tropical cardinalfish Cheilodipterus quinquelineatus.

Wrasse Pteragogus pelycus.
Even our red mullets have been replaced by a Red Sea species, Parupeneus forsskali.

Tropical goatfish Parupeneus forsskali.
A very common tropical species of parrotfish, Scarus ghobban, which lives in practically all parts of the tropical Indo-Pacific, has also appeared. At least this species has not displaced the native Sparisoma cretense.

Tropical parrotfish Scarus ghobban.
Although I complained at the start that there were few fish, I can say that there are more groupers in Turkey than in Croatia or Italy. The dominant species are the dusky grouper Epinephelus marginatus and the golden grouper Epinephelus costae, and with a bit of luck you can also see the mottled grouper Mycteroperca rubra, otherwise an Atlantic species. Turkish groupers are, on average, considerably larger than Croatian ones. The grouper is a fish that changes sex.

Male golden grouper Epinephelus costae.
Young groupers are female and older ones male. The golden grouper also changes colour as it changes sex. The female is brown and striped, while males turn grey, the stripes disappear and a large golden patch appears on the upper flank. Such males are extremely rare in the Adriatic, because fishermen unfortunately catch them before they manage to change sex… With a great deal of luck, I also managed to find a juvenile golden grouper, about three centimetres long, with yellow fins.

Juvenile golden grouper Epinephelus costae.
On the groupers I occasionally saw another tropical fish – the sharksucker or remora (Echeneis naucrates), which in tropical seas is very common on sharks.

Dusky grouper Epinephelus marginatus with a remora Echeneis naucrates.
Besides fishing, overly warm water and the absence of currents are probably the main culprits behind the disappearance of fish
The presence of large groupers and the absence of discarded fish traps, nets and longlines, which densely litter the Croatian part of the Adriatic, make me think that Turkish fishermen may not be the main reason for the disappearance of fish, as they are in Croatia. In Levent’s view, the main culprits in recent years are overly warm water and the absence of currents, which used to be quite common. In addition, loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) have multiplied – I actually saw quite a few – and they have eaten a lot of the seagrass, which is also very important as a hiding place for juvenile fish.

Loggerhead turtle Caretta caretta.
Levent also told me that he had spotted a new species of shrimp among the Diadema urchins. From then on I watched the urchins hiding in crevices closely and shone my torch on them, but found nothing. I was expecting small, transparent shrimps. On the second dive that Levent guided, however, he called me over at one point and pointed to an urchin. For a fleeting moment, a fraction of a second, I glimpsed the hairy legs characteristic of tropical shrimps of the genus Saron, but it all happened too quickly for me to be sure. It also seemed utterly unbelievable, as this is a typically tropical species that lives among corals and only comes out at night. Levent also warned me that this shrimp dislikes light and retreats as soon as you shine a torch on it.
On one of the following dives, in a dark canyon, I spotted the shrimp myself beside a Diadema urchin and confirmed that it really did belong to the genus Saron. Unfortunately, I could not get a good shot, because the shrimp immediately hid among the urchin’s spines. But it was enough for me to identify it. It was the species Saron marmoratus, which I had occasionally, though rarely, encountered on night dives in the Red Sea. These shrimps are quite large and very colourful – in short, among the most beautiful shrimps in the sea. Then and there I set myself the goal of taking at least one technically successful photograph of this wonderful shrimp (which should not be in the Mediterranean at all…).
Unfortunately, I was not very successful. I did not find the shrimp on a single urchin again. On the last day of diving we headed to a rather distant site, with two dives planned. On the first dive we were joined by an older German diving instructor who lives in Kaş and knows the local sea extremely well. She did indeed find me quite a few tiny creatures, including a small transparent shrimp, Urocaridella pulchella, which is also originally a tropical species but acquired Turkish citizenship long ago, as I had already seen it on my first visits to Turkey. Unfortunately, she did not find me a Saron, as there were also far fewer urchins there.

Shrimp Urocaridella pulchella.
On the second dive Magda and I were on our own, as the German instructor complained that she was cold and said she never does more than one dive a day. This time we found nothing special. My hopes of photographing the Saron faded. But just as in Calabria, where, quite miraculously, on the last day I was given the chance to dive in a small kelp forest, a miracle happened in Turkey too.
Although I was convinced my request would not be granted, on the way back to the home harbour I nevertheless asked Levent whether there was any chance of a third dive. To my surprise, he granted my request and, what is more, offered to guide me himself. So just the three of us – Levent, Magda and I – set off on this dive, while the other twenty divers waited for us on the boat.
Levent already knew very well what my great wish was and told me he would try to make it come true. He took a large children’s sandpit rake with him on the dive – I really have no idea how it ended up on his boat. Once we had descended, it quickly became clear to me what he had in mind: he used the rake to coax the urchins out of the crevices. Many people would be appalled by this, but here we are again with that double standard whereby touching marine animals is unacceptable, yet eating seafood is perfectly acceptable! He did not injure a single urchin in the process, and they quickly retreated into new holes.
And behind the urchins, the shrimps were hiding. There were far more of them than I had expected; on this dive I saw about twenty! Every time he moved an urchin aside, one would appear, but it quickly hid deeper among the rocky crevices. It was already late afternoon and dark, the shrimps were in shady crevices, and I could not use a light, otherwise they would have retreated even faster. Photography was therefore very demanding, and I have only the excellent autofocus of my Nikon D850 to thank for managing a few technically successful shots in those dark conditions, where I could barely see the shrimps with my own eyes.

Shrimp Saron marmoratus.
The photograph of the Saron shrimp was the highlight of my photographic trip to Turkey, so I can say that, despite the absence of large numbers of fish, it was quite a success. At the same time came the realisation that changes in the sea are very complex, that fishermen are not the only culprits, and that many other factors are at play which we are still far from understanding.